D – Dilithium

“Ye cannae break th’ laws o’ physics, Cap’n!”

– Chief Engineer Montgomery “Scotty” Scott

In the Star Trek universe, plots abound which involve time travel, (matter) transporters, matter replicators (don’t get me started) – and of course warp drive.  When you are dealing with a big volume of space, encompassing thousands of alien races, you need a way of getting from A to B in a useful amount of time.  To put things in perspective, Voyager 1, launched in 1977, has travelled a whopping 135 AU (Astronomical Units) or ~2 x 1010 km, but this is less than 0.002 light years.  Wheeling out the popular yard- (light-year) stick, our closest neighbouring star is Alpha Centauri, a mere 4.3 light years away. (I’m simplifying a little, as I don’t want to get distracted – Alpha Centauri is actually a binary pair with a third star, Proxima Centauri, a smidge closer to Earth, but it’s a lot smaller, and it doesn’t have the same cachet).

(As an aside, for those you remember, and care, the Motion Picture had at its literal and metaphorical heart V’ger, which was the fictional Voyager 6, upgraded by sentient machines and itself becoming sentient.  Voyager 6 was launched in “the second half of the 20th Century”.  The only way for the plot to work, because Voyager has to pass from mortal ken, is that it travels via a wormhole to the other side of the galaxy.  If it were going at the same speed as Voyager 1 then it would be a mere 0.015 light years away from Earth by the time Bill et al are boldly going.  Space is really, really big).

So, you need to get places fast – we might actually want to get to Alpha Centauri as it might just have an Earth-like planet around it.  So you need a method of propulsion. If this were a purely physics post, then I’d dust off the popular ‘Twins Paradox’.  Most people are so familiar with this though that I’m not going to go through the mechanics of this.  The upshot, however, is that it is not merely enough to be able to travel fast, you need to do so in a way such that time flows for everyone (inside the ship and on various planets) at more or less the same rate.

Which brings us to D for Dilithium.  Dilithium is so key to Star Trek that it became an essential plot point in the brilliant parody Galaxy Quest (By Grabthar’s Hammer!)*.  Strictly speaking dilithium is Li2, but in the Star Trek Universe it is a hard mineral which is only rarely found in nature.  A further conundrum is that dilithium is stated to be an element: on the periodic table that is shown from time to time it comes up as element 87, which to us is francium.  There are two possible explanations.  One is that the scientists of the future have a very different approach to the use of the periodic table and the form that we have been looking at is actually a form of inventory of usable elements/alloys.  Alternatively, who knows where science has taken us in the future (apart from to the Final Frontier, of course).  Hence, what we might be looking at is a series of very complex ‘modified’ atoms, some of which can turn up naturally.  What we do know is that initially it was impossible to produce high quality crystals synthetically, but this problem was overcome sometime between The Original Series and Next Generation, which allowed for much bigger fleets to be built.

*Realised here as beryllium spheres: the parody is spot on, but the science is more flaky than a croissant.

The crystals are only a part of a complicated energy generation procedure (‘Electro-Plasma System’, EPS), but one of the more critical parts, hence the focus on this part of the engine room.  The (Star Trek) theory is that the mineral structure can be energised in such a way that it can produce a complex electro-magnetic field structure that can be used to manipulate anti-matter (anti-matter again!) – the nature of the fields means that the antimatter never comes into contact with the crystals, but can be controlled and directed so that it reacts with matter in order to heat deuterium and form a plasma.

In a “that’s your problem with this?” moment, it should be noted that dilithium crystals need to be recharged periodically.  Most notably this occurred in Star Trek IV: The Voyage Home, which required the crystals to be recharged in order that the Klingon Bird of Prey can return back to the future, to coin a phrase… What is not entirely clear is why this might be the case.  There are situations where a mineral or chemical is consumed or leaks (e.g. refrigeration gases, particularly those found in car air-conditioning systems), but this should not be the case here – the crystal is energised and creates a field.  It’s possible that over time the crystal structure becomes degraded due to mobility of the atoms, exacerbated by the energies involved, but simply putting the crystals in a nuclear reactor is not really going to help.

Given that there is widespread use of magnetic fields to control the flow of plasmas already, this seems like an inconvenient way of controlling the whole process.  Should such a mineral exist (or be capable of being synthesised) it is not certain whether it would be capable of producing the effects described – but it’s fun pseudo-science, so what the heck.


Afterword: Researchers at the University of Huntsville are looking a potential propulsion system which came to light whilst I was researching this post.  Whilst in no way a warp drive, nor yet ‘real dilithium’, it’s still an interesting read, and an example of how to get the press interested in your story.


16 thoughts on “D – Dilithium

    1. Very true. But if someone is doing something based in reality, then they really need to get it right. Likewise there does need to be some internal consistency in the science/magic, in my opinion.

      Liked by 1 person

  1. When I was in college “Scotty” came to campus to speak. Not as a scientist, but as a human being with an interesting career based on playing a specific character. He was funny in real life, and admitted that he hadn’t a clue about the science of Star Trek. Dilithium crystals, his TV character’s stock and trade, meant nothing to him. The sci-fi geeks in the audience were so bummed.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. That is brilliant! Reminds me of a comedy sketch of William Shatner at a convention being asked questions. An uber-geek asked about the number of the safe and is told that it’s just TV, it’s not really real…

      Liked by 1 person

  2. Ever since I heard about superatoms, it’s been my personal head canon that dilithium is a superatom that incorporates two lithium atoms. I have no idea if that’s consistent with real-life superatoms or with what we’re told about dilithium on the show, but I like to think of it that way.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Agreed. Bujold did a brilliant job of keeping it simple and Chris Baldwin of the webcomic Spacetrawler has a good, humourous take. But I do think this is one where you take it for granted that the operation is complex but routine, that nobody cares and you paper over the cracks by saying how it makes you feel ill etc…

      Liked by 1 person

      1. Exactly. Coming up with unusual side-effects is fun though. On a related but slightly different tack, I did like the touch in the film version of HHGG, where you could tell how far you’d travelled in whatever the transporter beam was called, by the change in length of your towel.

        Liked by 1 person

  3. There you go. I was right about D being dilithium but wrong that didn’t involve antimatter. I’d make a better commander than an engineer. Don’t tell me how you’re going to do it, just do it. But I’m enjoying your posts.

    Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s